NEW
To Titusville →
For YOU!
A Different Take on Pizza!!!
Serving a variety of pizzas, entrees, hand-cut fries, Mac and Cheese bowls, cheese breads, pizza sandwiches, salads, calzones, homemade desserts & more!
Made to EXCITE
YOUR
👅 Taste Buds 👅
We strive to consistently use local fresh organic produce and real quality ingredients to provide mouth watering pizzas to Titusville and neighboring communities.
CHICAGO TAVERN STYLED PIZZAS
We incorporated and fusionend our pizzas from the midwest and brought it here to Titusville. Our crust is thin, crispy, chewy, flavorful, and firm with a crunch!
- Specialty cheeses
- High-end flour
- Lots of toppings
- Lots of sauces
100+
Pizzas
Made to order
25+
Specialty Pizzas
Made to impress
100%
Authentic & Real
Made with love
4.6 Stars
Customer Reviews
Made to be shared
Tasted by over 100s
of happy customers
Don’t just take our word for it, read what members of our friendly community have to say about us.
This isn’t your average pizza joint. This pizza has soul. The crust is amazingly crispy even when overloaded with greasy toppings. I am not sure how but they do it but it breaks the laws of physics. This place is a must stop if you’ve never had it.
Kyle Winning
I thought when I placed my large pizza order for pickup and got the total that they seemed a little pricier than the prior establishment, but when I got there I saw where my money went. Much bigger pizza, and WOW, that crust! Crunchy and delicious, albeit a little messy, but aren’t the best foods messy? They also re-invented the inside of the place and it looks much better. Keep up the good work, I will be back.
Tom Shelley
I haven’t actually been inside yet but my husband has picked up To-Go orders twice; Absolute perfection! These pizzas are amazing, I don’t know what they do differently from other pizza shops but their pies are a thousand times better than anywhere else. This is my new favorite place, highly recommend.
Snick
This was my first visit to Grumbley’s! When I got there the pizza was ready and the half cheese bread wasn’t but they solved that issue and gave me a full size for the inconvenience. The cheese bread was phenomenal! By the time I got home the pizza was cold. I give places like these a second chance, it’s a new business and people are still in that training process! Everyone was so kind! I would definitely recommend this place!
Isabelle Legaspi
Yeah new favorite pizza joint for sure. With way more than just pizza! Wife really loved the salad. They made my “Dirty Hawaiian” for me. Great job! You’re going to do amazing! We will be regulars!
Dave’s Event Videos
Plenty of parking. Clean interior. Large selection. Excellent service. Our pizza was delicious. The crust was perfection! Golden brown and crispy. Not hard or soggy or burnt . Fresh toppings. We got the personal size which are 9”. Drinks are sold in cans not fountain style. You can eat at the window at the bar style seating but it’s limited and more for waiting. Parties larger than 2 should consider take out as there are no tables. We don’t live close by but could easily grab a pizza and drive over to a close park and eat there picnic style.
Heather Coleman
Ready to take your taste buds to the next level?
Place your order now.